Week 11 Start/Sit: Start David Montgomery Over Emmett Johnson

David Montgomery
David Montgomery • HOU • RB

Week 11's first lineup decision lands Thursday. David Montgomery comes back from a groin injury with Woody Marks in the concussion protocol, and you have to settle him against Emmett Johnson before Kenneth Walker's Friday practice tells you anything. Start Montgomery: with Marks out, he leads a Houston backfield whose other options are Emari Demercado and Dare Ogunbowale, and the Colts listed two starting tackles and both starting corners as non-participants Monday and Tuesday, with Wednesday's final report still to come.

Kenneth Walker
Kenneth Walker • KC

Half-PPR scoring.

Receipts

  • Week 9 Saturday, start Omar Cooper Jr.: miss, 9.8 points, WR30. Eleven targets that week weren't enough. Today we flip him to a sit, because his ankle gave out again on the Jets' first play of Week 10.
  • Week 9 Saturday, sit Alvin Kamara: hit, 6.4 points, RB32. He stays on the bench.

Quarterback

Start Cam Ward over Kirk Cousins. Dallas allows 20.3 half-PPR points a game to quarterbacks this season, third-most. Tennessee put Wan'Dale Robinson on IR Tuesday with an ankle injury. His 38 catches went for only 272 yards, 7.2 a catch, so the targets moving to Elic Ayomanor and possibly Carnell Tate should travel farther. Cousins won his first start back against Green Bay, but Jordan Addison's thumb surgery costs him his second receiver for multiple weeks. San Francisco is a middling quarterback matchup this season (17th). Flip to Cousins if Tate is ruled out Friday and T.J. Hockenson practices in full.

Kirk Cousins
Kirk Cousins • MIN

Sit Geno Smith. Imaging found no major damage to the ankle he rolled Sunday. Even so, the Jets have gone nine quarters without a touchdown, and rookie Cade Klubnik starts if Smith can't.

Geno Smith
Geno Smith • NYJ

Running Back

Start David Montgomery over Emmett Johnson. Marks took a concussion in Sunday's 27-24 loss to Cleveland, and DeMeco Ryans said there's "just not enough time" for him on a short week. Marks sat out both estimated practices. Montgomery was listed full on both, after a groin injury that had kept him out since Week 5. Behind him are Emari Demercado, who ran seven times for 16 yards Sunday, and Dare Ogunbowale.

Montgomery played over half the snaps in three of his four healthy games. Indianapolis allows 23.0 points a game to backs this season, sixth-most. Raimann, Travis, Gardner and Ward all missed both Colts practices. Houston is a 12.5-point favorite, which points to a fourth quarter full of handoffs. The risk is a pitch count in his first game in six weeks, but half of this backfield beats a backup's share of someone else's.

Johnson's Week 10 was loud: 22 carries for 101 yards, plus six catches for 70 and two scores, all with Walker out. Ian Rapoport reports Walker is expected to be cleared for Arizona, and before Sunday Johnson never topped 36% of the snaps. The case for Johnson is Kansas City as a 16.5-point favorite with late carries to hand out. Rapoport has since said he wouldn't be surprised if Kansas City gave Walker another week, and Johnson doesn't need a touchdown even with Walker active: he caught five passes for 128 yards in the loss at Denver. Montgomery still gets the call because his lock comes first and Marks is out, but Johnson is a hold, not a sit. Flip to Johnson if Wednesday's final Texans report rules Montgomery out.

Sit Kaelon Black. Tuesday's add was a stash. He played 26 of 65 snaps in Week 10 behind a healthy Christian McCaffrey, and Minnesota allows the fifth-fewest RB points this season.

Sit Alvin Kamara. New Orleans activated Travis Etienne Jr. from IR before Week 10, and Kamara played 25% of the snaps. Two touchdowns on that share won't repeat at Chicago with the Saints 11.5-point underdogs.

Alvin Kamara
Alvin Kamara • NO

Wide Receiver

Start Adonai Mitchell over Omar Cooper Jr. Cooper hurt his ankle again on the opening play Sunday, and Aaron Glenn needs more tests to learn whether it's a high or low sprain. Mitchell has played at least 87% of the snaps in each of the last two games and drew 15 targets over them. The Chargers allow 30.1 WR points a game this season, fourth-most. Flip to Cooper only if he practices in full Friday.

Start Elic Ayomanor over Tre Tucker. Ayomanor caught five passes for 79 yards in Week 10. Robinson's IR stint frees up targets, but Ayomanor has to split them with Calvin Ridley, Chimere Dike, newly promoted Xavier Restrepo and possibly Carnell Tate. The matchup makes the call, not a guaranteed bump. Dallas allows the sixth-most WR points this season. Tucker draws a Denver defense allowing the sixth-fewest, with the Raiders implied for 15.3 points.

Tight End

Start Tyler Warren Thursday. Two catches for one yard in Week 10 came on an 86% snap share, the same role he's had all year. He's still first at tight end on the Colts' depth chart, with Drew Ogletree behind him. Ogletree is a backup, not a threat to the job. Houston allows the seventh-fewest TE points, and he's still your tight end. Put the phone down.

Start T.J. Hockenson over Dallas Goedert. Addison's surgery leaves Cousins without his second receiver, and Hockenson drew seven targets in Week 9, his last game. Kevin O'Connell expects him to progress from the wrist and chest injuries that kept him out of Week 10. Goedert gets a 17-point implied total and a newly signed Zach Ertz in his position room.

Dallas Goedert
Dallas Goedert • PHI

Injury Fallbacks

  • Montgomery (groin): He plays. Start him. If he's ruled out Wednesday, pivot to Johnson. Demercado, next up in Houston, is only a volume flier.
  • Walker (groin): Unresolved. Ian Rapoport said Tuesday he wouldn't be surprised if Kansas City sat Walker another week to let the groin heal fully. Keep Johnson rostered and in your Sunday plans until the Chiefs' practice reports show how much Walker is doing. If Walker sits, Johnson is an RB2. If Walker practices in full by Friday and nothing points to a limited workload, Johnson drops to a flex.
  • Carnell Tate (shoulder): Robert Saleh said Monday he's hoping Tate returns. He hasn't played since Week 7, so this is a hope, not a return. Start him as a WR2 on his 26% target share this season only if he practices in full and carries no game designation Friday. Anything less, use the fallback. If Friday's report rules him out, start Ryan Flournoy, Dallas's No. 3 receiver, against a Titans defense allowing the most WR points this season.
  • Jaylen Waddle (concussion): His 19% snap share in Week 9 came from the concussion, not a role change, and the Week 10 bye gave him two weeks to clear. He hasn't cleared the protocol yet; Mike Klis reports only that he could have a chance to before the Raiders game. Start him against a Raiders defense allowing the seventh-most WR points if he's cleared and practicing without limits by Friday. If he isn't cleared by Friday, start Jalen Coker, Carolina's 80%-snap receiver in Week 10, against Baltimore.
  • Hockenson (wrist, chest): Limited isn't enough in his first week back from the wrist and chest injuries, because Kevin O'Connell has only said he hopes Hockenson will be available. Start him if he gets in a full practice by Friday or comes off the report with no game designation. If he's questionable for the Sunday night kickoff in Mexico City, start Goedert, whose game kicks off at 10 a.m. PT.
  • Geno Smith (ankle): Sit him either way.

Cheat Sheet

Start Over Matchup Flip
Montgomery (Thu) E. Johnson IND allows 6th-most RB pts; HOU -12.5 Ruled out Wednesday → Johnson
Ward Cousins DAL allows 3rd-most QB pts Tate out and Hockenson full Friday → Cousins
Mitchell Cooper LAC allows 4th-most WR pts Cooper full Friday
Ayomanor Tucker DAL allows 6th-most WR pts None before lock
Warren (Thu) — HOU allows 7th-fewest TE pts None before lock
Hockenson (if full Friday) Goedert Addison out after surgery Not full or questionable Friday → Goedert
Tate (if full Friday) Flournoy DAL allows 6th-most WR pts Not full or questionable Friday → Flournoy
Waddle (if cleared) Coker LV allows 7th-most WR pts Not cleared or limited Friday → Coker

Sit: Geno Smith, Black, Kamara, Cooper, Tucker, Goedert, Cousins. Hold: E. Johnson, until Kansas City's practice reports settle Walker's status. Weather: Nothing to bench for. Steelers-Eagles' 40% chance of light rain is the worst kickoff forecast.

FCT Weekly

Get the next FCT read in your inbox.

The FCT Weekly turns rankings, player news, and market movement into draft, waiver, and lineup context you can use before your league reacts.